Local Artisan Shop
About The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op in Olean NY
Supporting Handmade Gifts, Crafts, and Community Makers
Free Coffee Bar
Enjoy our free coffee bar for our customers! Treat yourself to complimentary coffee, tea, water, or goodies to enjoy as you shop.
Fowler's Chocolates
We now carry a large selection of Fowler's Chocolates. They can be added to any order or enjoyed as a sweet treat anytime!
Community Care Delivery
One of our most appreciated features is free local delivery to hospitals and nursing homes within the Olean area. This service allows customers to send thoughtful gifts directly to loved ones who may need a little extra care and attention.
100% Free Delivery
to Nursing homes and Hospitals in Olean
Welcome to a Locally Loved Artisan Shop in Olean, NY
The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op is more than just a gift shop in Olean NY. It is a place where creativity, community, and craftsmanship come together. For nearly 30 years, the shop has been a trusted destination for customers seeking handmade gifts, locally made products, and a welcoming shopping experience.
Located at 2330 West State Street in Olean, NY, directly across from Tops Supermarket, the store has become a familiar and beloved part of the community. What started as a small craft shop has grown into a thriving artisan marketplace featuring the work of over 30 talented local makers.
Every item in the shop reflects the passion and dedication of the people who create it. From carefully poured candles to hand-designed home décor, each product offers a level of detail and authenticity that cannot be replicated by mass-produced goods.
30+
local artisans
Our Story and 29 Years of Community Connection
Cindy’s Craft Co-op has proudly served the Olean area for nearly three decades. Originally known as Cindy’s Crafts Co-Op, the business has maintained its core mission while evolving to meet the needs of modern shoppers.
Throughout the years, the shop has remained committed to supporting local artisans and small businesses. By providing a space where creators can showcase and sell their work, The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op helps keep local craftsmanship alive and thriving.
The longevity of the business speaks to the trust it has built within the community. Generations of customers have visited the shop for holidays, celebrations, and everyday moments, making it a meaningful part of their traditions.
Today, the co-op continues to grow while staying true to its roots. It remains focused on offering high-quality handmade gifts in Olean NY while fostering a strong sense of connection between customers and creators.
Why Supporting Local Artisans Matters
At The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op, every purchase has a purpose. Shopping at a local artisan shop in Olean NY directly supports individuals who are passionate about their craft and dedicated to producing high-quality goods.
Unlike large retail chains, where products are often manufactured in bulk, the items found in the shop are made in small batches. This allows artisans to focus on quality, creativity, and detail. Customers benefit by receiving unique items that stand out and feel personal.
Supporting local artisans also strengthens the community. It helps small businesses grow, encourages creativity, and keeps money circulating within the region. This creates a positive impact that extends far beyond a single purchase.
Whether it is handmade jewelry, seasonal decorations, or artisan home décor, each product represents the skill and dedication of local makers. This connection between creator and customer is what makes shopping at Cindy’s Craft Co-op a truly meaningful experience.
What You’ll Find at Cindy’s Craft Co-op
The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op offers a diverse and ever-changing selection of products, ensuring that every visit brings something new to explore. The shop features a wide range of locally made crafts in Olean NY, carefully curated to appeal to different styles and occasions.
Customers can browse items such as handmade candles, soaps, and jewelry, along with greeting cards, tumblers, and kitchen décor. The shop also carries seasonal decorations, country-style home décor, and boutique gift items that reflect the charm of a rustic, small-town aesthetic.
Specialty items like crystals, gemstones, and locally sourced honey add to the variety, while NFL apparel and custom embroidery services provide additional options for personalized gifts.
Because the inventory is supplied by multiple artisans, the selection is constantly evolving. This means customers can always find unique gifts in Olean NY that feel fresh, creative, and thoughtfully made.
Our Commitment to Thoughtful Service
At The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op, customer service is just as important as the products themselves. The goal is to create a shopping experience that feels welcoming, personal, and stress-free.
One of the most valued services offered is free local delivery to hospitals and nursing homes in the Olean area. This allows customers to send gifts directly to loved ones who may need comfort, encouragement, or celebration.
The shop also specializes in custom gift baskets. These can be tailored to fit any occasion, from birthdays and holidays to special milestones. Customers can choose from a variety of products to create a personalized gift that reflects their intentions and style.
In addition to local services, the shop offers nationwide shipping, making it possible to share locally made gifts with friends and family across the country. This combination of personal service and convenience sets the business apart as a leading gift shop in Olean NY.
FAQs About The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op
How long has Cindy’s Craft Co-op been in business?
The shop has been serving the Olean community for nearly 30 years, building a strong reputation for quality and local support.
How many artisans are featured in the shop?
The store proudly features products from over 30 local artisans, offering a wide variety of handmade goods.
Do you only sell locally made products?
The focus is primarily on locally made crafts and artisan goods, with a carefully curated selection of complementary boutique items.
Can I request a custom gift basket?
Yes, custom gift baskets are available and can be created for any occasion, with options for both local delivery and nationwide shipping.
Do you offer delivery services?
Yes, free local delivery is available exclusively to hospitals and nursing homes in the Olean area.
Where is the shop located?
The shop is located at 2330 West State Street in Olean, NY, across from Tops Supermarket.
Visit Us and Experience the Difference
The New Cindy’s Craft Co-op continues to be a cornerstone of the local shopping experience in Olean NY. With a focus on handmade gifts, community support, and personalized service, the shop offers something that larger retailers simply cannot match.
Customers are invited to visit the store and explore a wide selection of artisan products, meet the friendly team, and discover gifts that feel truly special. Whether shopping for a specific occasion or simply browsing for inspiration, every visit offers a chance to connect with the creativity and talent of local makers.
For those who cannot visit in person, the shop is always ready to assist with custom orders, gift baskets, and shipping options.
PHONE
location
2330 West State Street, Olean, NY 14760 — Serves Olean, NY and surrounding ~30-mile radius
Experience a local artisan shop in Olean NY where quality, creativity, and community come together in every detail.
